Welcome to our pie menu!
Pie – there’s always room for a slice of heaven! Explore our pie selection, featuring a delightful mix of traditional favorites, innovative creations, and unique flavor combinations.
To view our current pie offerings, pricing details, and discover our seasonal delights, simply click the ‘Order Online Now’ button. Treat yourself to a taste of goodness today
We request a week’s notice. Why do we request a week’s notice? We’re not your typical bakery. We’re a small boutique shop, and our commitment to quality is unwavering. Unlike larger establishments, we don’t rely on premade, frozen, or bucketed ingredients.
Every item we offer is crafted from scratch, customized to your desires. This means we take orders one week, carefully plan, and execute those orders the following week. It’s a meticulous process that ensures each creation meets our high standards.
By adhering to this schedule, we can typically accommodate all orders and maintain the level of excellence our customers expect.
The Sublime! Our key lime pie – a majestic treat to finish off your next picnic or family gathering
There are two schools of thought when it comes to baking a key lime pie… the kind you bake and the kind you don’t. And there are equal numbers of people that line up for both. So, we combined them into our own version. First we take our traditional key lime pie recipe and bake it in a graham cracker lined pan. When that is cool, we add another layer of key lime pie that is the “other side”…. We then finish it off with a lime whipped cream, garnish it will slices of lime and lime zest. This recipe makes an utterly divine pie, and is my personal favorite!*
The Old Fashioned!  Chocolate Cream Pie – makes your grandmother smileÂ
No French Silk Pie or Chocolate Chiffon Pie or Chocolate Chess Pie variations with this one!
Our chocolate pie recipe goes back to those your grandmothers used to make. A luscious pure chocolate pie filling poured into a chocolate cookie crust. We start with real bittersweet and semi-sweet chocolate, whole milk and heavy cream, sweet butter, eggs, a little sugar… cooked to a creamy pudding. Garnished with freshly whipped cream, a drizzle of chocolate ganache… or sprinkles. Consider these variations: We can always add a caramel sauce, chopped roasted walnuts, chopped pecans… Just old fashioned chocolate goodness!*
Traditional Peanut Butter Pie – a dessert for all agesÂ
Peanut Butter takes the lead in this melt in your mouth treat. Made with a chocolate cookie crust this pie is filled to the rim with a sensational creamy peanut butter mousse filling made with ingredients that include peanut butter, cream cheese and cream. Glazed with a dark chocolate ganache and sprinkled with crushed peanuts. A must for every special event menu.
Grasshopper Pie!
This green pie is flavored with creme de menthe! With a little help from cream cheese and heavy cream… a few other ingredients. This pie is egg free.
The Chase! Cut right to it… Let’s not waste any time getting to the best pie on earth! Â
Our traditional old fashioned chocolate pie is on the top, our melt in your mouth peanut butter pie on the bottom, covered with a chocolate ganache… oh my! You have to close your eyes when you take your first bite so you will remember to breathe. It’s that good.
Banana Cream – a dreamy, creamy dessert that always delights – It’s got fresh bananas… so it’s healthy right? It’s worth the calories!Â
We start with a buttery crust. Add to that our scratch made vanilla pudding. And I assure you, this is a pudding that will satisfy your heart and soul. Starting from our favorite ingredients: sugar, whole milk, cream, and egg yolks. This pie is loaded with sliced bananas… the pudding just holds them together so you can slice the pie! Consider these variations: We can always add a few bananas on the top, or make the pie with a chocolate or sugar cookie crust… add a little whipped cream with a few crushed peanuts…*
Dutch Apple Pie –  baked to sweet flaky perfection!  For your holiday season try our apple and cranberry pies!
We start with a buttery flakey pie crust… add to that tart apples…. A little spice, butter, sugar… Our traditional apple pie is all about the apples, with that flakey buttery crust on the bottom topped with a cinnamon butter crumb. Consider these variations: Adding something special… bring in the spring with some blueberry? Welcome fall with a little cranberry? Just choose in our online menu.
Lemon Cloud – you’ll die and go to heaven with every biteÂ
Made with a graham cracker crust…. Add a base layer of our cream cheese lemon pie then add our amazing lemon curd pie filling made with a little lemon juice, sugar, some zest and some of our favorite ingredients to create a sweet symphony of lemony goodness. Garnished with a Chantilly cream of course! Go ahead, give into temptation! Pictured above
The Sweet Tea! – our honey bourbon pecan pie…  Â
Grab a glass of sweet tea with this one, it doesn’t get any more southern than this! Made with local Waynesville honey, a good dose of Bourbon, and of course pecans. We won’t serve it right away… we let it sit just enough for that Bourbon to kick it up a notch. You will stay home for dinner with this one!
The Toast! – our pumpkin pie…  Â
A little toast on the pumpkin gives this pie a true pumpkin flavor. Holiday spices take it the rest of the way. Made with our flaky savory crust and served with a cinnamon whipped cream topping. A must for your Thanksgiving table!
Coconut Dream! – All coconut…Â
Baked in a buttery flaky pie crust. Add to that our incredible coconut cream that you find in our hand pies! Garnished with a whipped cream and toasted coconut.
Coconut and Chocolate! Yep, you guessed it! Â
Yes indeed! Our Old Fashioned chocolate pie topped with our coconut cream and toasted coconut. Â
Roasted apple/cranberry cheesecake pie Â
Our fall favorite apple/cranberry cheesecake baked in a pie format. For those that want that great dessert for their holiday table, but in a smaller serving size.
*Variations may increase the price slightly